Is this the same deer? update .....I'm convinced I have an answer

[Guru]

I think it probably is, but to me the deer in the video has longer tines....what do you think?

   


 

[Hot Hap]

Agree-Longer tines in the video. Hap

[Ontario Longbow]

Tough call,, but I believe it the same buck,,Frank

[steadman]

Definetly longer tines in the video. Good luck on those Curt!

[bigbuckmalik]

After watchin the video about 30 times, i'd say yes. At the very end did you notice G4's on the video buck, or did i just stare too long?

[gregg dudley]

Looks like the same deer to me, Curt.  The picture shows the deer facing you , which to me is the hardest angle to judge anything about a rack.  The G2 on the left main beam is a long tine and shows up nicer in the video than the picture.

[bigbuckmalik]

By the way, i didnt mean that 4's would make it different, you cant tell in the still picture anyway.  Just wondered if anyone else saw the same thing

[Guru]

Oh I know he's got G-4's      

Here's a still of the video buck....

 


And a close up of the still pic buck.....

 

[Widowbender]

That's not the same deer...

David

[Killdeer]

Nope.  

[Bjorn]

I'm with Killy!

[gregg dudley]

Kurt, LOL, now you post the worst possible way to judge a rack (straight on) vs. the most flattering (from the back at an angle).  Why don't you go shoot the bad boy and see if the pictures stop.  I still think it is the same deer.

Gregg

[Lin Rhea]

Different Buck. I could easily miss either one.    Lin

[DRR324]

video buck has longer G2's than his 3s.  Picture buck looks to have close to the same length 2s and 3s. Different bucks imo.
Dave

[Jack Denbow]

Curt, the best way to tell is to shoot one and see if the other one shows up.  

[Izzy]

Hes a "nuther" buck than the still I believe.If you tell me exactly where hes located I could tell you better.

[Bear]

Differnt deer fer shur.

The right side G2 is the give-away, to me anyway.

[flatlander37]

Two different deer in my opinion

[3dmuzzy]

Curt,not a problem I'll help you out,we can sit 100 yards apart if we shoot one buck they were the same " sound like a deal" LOL.......ED

[Guru]

I'm really starting to think they're two different bucks...

Video buck seems to have longer points and better mass than the still pic buck....Still pic buck seems to be a little stouter in the body.  But we all know pix and video can be very deceiving...

I have the camera in there now and it's set for video.It's been there for a week and a half now. Probably won't get to check till Sunday. So hopefully we'll get to the bottom of this soon.

Thanx guys