I like the PBS because they do include those who shoot the wheelie majigs.
As far as equipment, my opinion is that most if not all bowhunters who embrace traditional ethics and hunting values eventually migrate to the simple stick and string. Some do it more quickly than others. It took me longer than most.
Let me explain:
I began bowhunting in 1986 with a boat anchor that happened to have wheels. My best friend and his family introduced me to it.
After the first year I was hooked. That first year I noticed several things. First, I liked to shoot, I shot leaves, spots on stumps, blades of grass, at an odd color. I shot all those things that first year, and continued to do it before I knew it was called stump shooting. I was and still am accused of carrying more judos than broadheads, when I hunt.
Those good friends are still friends, but we've gone down two different paths, they no longer hunt with their bows, and their hunting values are not the same as mine. As I was working my way through the thicket of hunting ethics and values, I spent some serious time evaluating my actions and measuring them agains what I saw from others, this in part created who I am today. The larger part of that process was influenced by a good friend and mentor who ultimately untroduced me to the PBS.
After 16+ years, I finally picked up my first recurve and felt that I'de come home. It was to a place I'de always been, but never sat to enjoy it. Now I'm more comfortable hunting folaige, fin, feather, and fur with my longbow, than any other equipment.
IMO - the whole traditional/professional thing is more a state of mind. The PBS has struggeled with carrying the professional mantra. I thought (and I'm sure others have perscieved) it (the PBS) was a group of snooty people with lots of money which allowed them to hunt professionaly.
The truth of it is that they are a group with traditional hunting values who have committed to hold one another to the highest standards. As a person enters the PBS they join of their own accord, they accept its standards and live by them. After being an associate member a person can (after they meet the requirements) apply to join the regular ranks. This includes some serious introspection, self evaluation and honesty, as well as having someone "sponsor" you based upon their knowledge and experience of your ethics and values (those may not be the right words). A person of "regular" status is expected to give back to the bowhunting community.
I'm proud to be a member of PBS, and encourage those I know who have the same values to join. It's not for every one but if it is for you then...
Welcome.