Tom,
Dentition showed all her baby teeth were gone with bicuspid molars & premolars. Some staining but not much. That would make her an 07 model by my count. My guess is a yearling cycling a bit odd, January seems really late. The spike was bizarre looking and acting as well. One antler was a foot long straight spike, the other was half as tall and twisted. His coat was dark & grizzled and he looked pretty bad. I think it has been a long season for him as well...Kept scent checking her and she didn't want anything to do with it.