Used it about 6 mos. I think it holds the feathers on better. Just my opinion. I think if you fletch your own the feathers stay on better in general anyway. Here's what I find:It's easier to use the glue since the tape takes a knack to roll off, etc esp if your fingers are kind of big and messed up like mine. But you don't have to wait for the glue to dry, so it goes fast. For me, if I'm doing one or a quick repair I use glue. If I'm going to make 6 or 12, I'll use tape, and maybe recruit a son or the Mrs to help peel the tape.
sam