I have hunted in all kinds of boots. I have two pairs of Meindle boots and a pair of Russell grand slam sheep hunting boots that are the cat's meow for hunting in the steepest, rockiest mountain country you can find. They have the vibram soles that are very tough, great traction bottoms but not so great for quiet stalking. Those good quality spendy boots however are not my favorites. I have an old pair of summer weight Rocky boots that are not insulated and not waterproof (anymore) that I prefer to wear most of the time. They fit like a pair of extra, extra hightop tennis shoes, lightweight and quiet with soft rubber soles that have some feel to them. The best boots for you are the ones that you like, the ones that are well broke in that won't hurt your feet after days and days of pounding and abuse. Waterproof is an important feature if you don't like wet feet. I hate wet feet myself but my favorite boots will be wet inside after the first morning. I bought a couple pairs of the waterproof goretex booties and I am going to try to get a few more seasons out of my old boots if I can get past them leaking so bad. Hate to give up on something that has worked so well for so long.