OK Here goes. I love to go hunting. Not so much for what I bag but the companions over the years I go with, which includes both my children, brother, and friends. I love to go sailing for the same reasons. Not that I don't enjoy the sport itself, but it would not be the same alone, although sometimes, I enjoy the time alone. Now why trad?
Why a sailboat rather than a powerboat? the challenge, the quiet, etc. Why a flintlock rather than a scoped bolt action 30-06? The sheer simplicity and challenge. And why a trad bow rather then a sighted wheel bow. same
I feel that by using the less technological tools, I get back closer to the sport, and in terms of hunting, I feel that I give the critters a certain respect they deserve, these great creatures with physical ability far beyond anything we will ever have. It's the tool and the intellect only that can challenge them. The hi powered rifle or even the modern wheel bow or cross bow is a no game situation. The only way to miss is to blow the shot.
With trad gear, no matter how hi tech it becomes, (btw I'm a wood arrow guy and I like the old classic bows), it's putting my skill with this tool, and a lot of the equation is me, up against their instincts, stamina and physical gifts and seeing how I measure up to nature.
OK now one more thing. Shoot a dozen arrows, and you can always do better. It's the constant challenge of perfecting that shot. There's an inexplicable joy of watching that arrow fly time after time and getting closer to that mark each time that never ceases to attract and amaze me.
OK someone else's turn.