Bow hunters for the trad bows and hunters for the compound make good choices, and they have worked very well for me.
I would try the bow hunter in the compound, but don't shoot it much anymore. I got 12 about that many years ago, and after shooting about 25 deer I still have 8 of them. I may never use them up at this rate. One I lost and three were robin hoods.
I have been shooting the bow hunters in trad bows about a year now, and so far other than robin hoods I have not broken one.
I have never had any problems with consistency, components or broad head tune issues.