Amen,Amicus.I have spun broadheads for 40 something years.I bought a spinning jig a few years ago and recently built another one because that one didn't work as well with some externally footed carbons.
I went back and checked some of my older arrows that I thought were well aligned by the old method and found they were off.
Spinning in the hand,you are looking for wobble in the shaft.Spinning on a jig,you have a stationary,pinpoint dot as a reference.With that,you can see any minute variance,probably down to thousand's of an inch.
Personally,I can't get it that fine,spinning in my hand.Using a jig,I had to admit that my broadhead alignment wasn't as good as I thought it was.
That bothered me a little but now that I am using the jig,I have never had better broadhead flight.I have always known I am not the quickest learner,but I guess"better late than never".
I'm not a target shooter.I'm a bowhunter and I don't take that responsibility lightly.I love old bows and old ways but if I can improve arrow flight,arrow sharpness,lethality,broadhead alignment,I owe that to the game I hunt.
It is tough at this age to try new things but I have always known that to not try new things,closes the door to any chance of improvement.I have never been real comfortable with the term"it's good enough".
I don't know when alignment jigs were first used but I do know that Jack Howard used them in the early 1970's.That was before most of today's"Trad" archers became Trad archers.
Maybe everyone can see minute shaft wobble better than I can.The jig makes it more precise for me.That is important to me and the game I hunt.I have enough human error.If I can eliminate equipment flaws,I do it.Kind of like tuning arrows to a bow for proper arrow flight.