I did start with a recurve as a child, mostly playing, with structure from my father, around in the yard. My father went through a phase with a compound right when I was hunting age and I started shooting a compound. I did however always have a tradbow to shoot. I hunted for almost 15 years with a compound of one kind or another. You know, have to have the latest and the greatest.
In the mid to late 90's I got to shooting the tradbow more and more would even hunt from time to time with it and did take a few animals while doing so... At the turn of the century I sat down and looked at the benefits of one style over the other. On one hand the compound had better long range accuracy, and even more pinpoint consistent accuracy. On the other hand the tradbow had a lot quicker point and shoot capability. At that point the difference in accuracy out to 20 yards was very slim. So, I weighed the odds of longer range accuracy vs. quicker point and shoot capability. Went over the previous animals I'd taken, and was unable to take, in a hunting situation. By and far I had more opportunities missed by not getting drawn and aimed on the animal at short range with a compound than I did from missed opportunities from having to pass shot opportunities because of effective range with the tradbow.
So, it was as true then as it is today, the tradbow is a more effective hunting weapon for me. Plus, over the years of hunting with only trad gear I've found very small changes in my stand setup and location has made missed long range opportunities less and less. Plus my effective range with the tradbow has gotten a bit longer even though everything needs to be perfect for longer range shots to be taken ethically for me...