bareshafting is a great tool in the beginning to start getting close. Especially for those who have a ton of shafts laying around in different spines (and spine testers or those that have been tested by ONE spine tester), or some different spined alum/carbons. Or for those who have friends with a crapload of shafts.
Group testing would be the next step, which at this point would almost be fine tuning. I still like to shoot through paper just for kicks.
Yes nock left is weak on a bare shaft. Nock high is USUALLY to high of a nock, try lowering it. A slight nock high is ok bareshafting. To low and you'll kick off the shelf.
I dont know why more people dont learn to bareshaft honestly before going to the ol method. It WAS the standard for quite some time, that and paper tuning. They are all tools in the bag of tricks to get your bow tuned perfect. If your form is that bad you cant bare shaft..maybe bareshafting is telling you something!
Razor, there are a lot of factors invovled in finding the right arrow...suprising or not what some will or wont do. I'd find a couple of those good shafts and find someone with a spine tester and try them. If you plan on shooting wood. You're not worried what bow those arrows were made for..you are worried more on the specifics of that arrow...total length from throat of nock to bop, tip weight, spine, and diameter of shaft. Also those nocks can play a factor in how a arrow flys, to tight on the string they'll act stiff..so if they snap on hard it's something you have to factor in!
Honestly I'd stop worrying about weight so much and find the right spined arrow that'll fly perfect. But take note what those ungodly heavy tipped arrows mean. Which is odd being adding all that weight up front even weaking the shaft more would allow it to fly better. Almost contradictory!