Steve....no one has really studied that aspect of it, so I'm not too sure of that "rattle those old bows apart" thing. Anyone can say what they want about that, but the fact is, it hasn't been studied. That's why I'm doing it on some old bows. No 59' Bears by the way.
From what I see, there is less shock from a skinny string of 450+, than there is from from a sixteen strand dacron....going on feel now. The bow is also quieter and more dead in the hand with the skinny 450.
I'm not saying for anyone to put them on vintage bows, but since no one will take up the challenge of trying it, then I suppose I have to.
I'm not buying the "old glue isn't as good thing." Shock is shock, vibration is vibration, and the old linen strings were about as no stretch as any modern material.
I've now shot my old Shakespeare at least 2000 shots with the skinny 450+, and I'm betting I'll get another times that many more shots. I have a 61 Polar that has a TS-1 string on it, and it has more than 500 shots through it, and also is less shocky on the shot.
You know maybe down the road, the old Shakespeare will break, but it isn't showing any signs, and from what I'm seeing, it is having to endure less vibration than it did with a 14 strand dacron, endless loop. Go figure.
I'm certainly not an expert, and was also one of those guys who swore by the B50 only theory for old bows. Bottom line is you guys need to do what you do and not compromise your bows if you think you will by shooting modern strings on them. As for me, I'm not convinced, so I'll keep plugging along and see if I get an en-masse failure from using the strings. I don't know at this time, but I have a gut feeling these old bows will hold up just fine.
I'll keep you posted if I do have a failure....I'm not afraid to pass that along if it happens 8^). We will see, for as they say, "nothing ventured....nothing gained."