Two years ago zI finally went into the Doc to have my right shoulder looked at. I had pain if I raised my hand over my head, and shooting was painful as well. I had Impingement Syndrome, which is caused by a swollen bursa and a bone spur in my shoulder. I had a couple of cortizone injections, which provided immediate although temporary relief. My last shot was to get me through an elk hunt, and it only lasted a few days.
When I returned, I scheduled the surgery. He removed the bone spur, and repaired a SLAP tear to the rotator cuff.( Fraying of the mucscle fibers from the spur rubbing across them). Fortunately, I did not have a torn rotator cuff, but he told if I had waited longer, eventually I would have.
The surgery sucked, I couldnt hardly button my pants for the first 2 weeks. But the Doc told me I'd be good to go in 8 weeks.
While he said I probably wouldnt need Physical Therapy, I pushed him for it, and I did 4 weeks 3 days a week. Those PT girls kicked my butt.
I followed the exercise regimen to the letter, and was shooting a light weight bow in 4 weeks, and was back up to my hunting bow in 8 weeks.
I was cleared back to work in 59 days. My shoulder is 100% now. Never would know i had it done by the way it feels. If you have impingement,surgery is the only way to fix it if its a bone spur. Do some research, and find the best orthopedic surgeon you can who specializes in shoulders. I did not take the decision for surgery lightly, but in the end I am glad I had it dome. To say with surgery you'll never be 100% afterwards is not true. I put up with pain, no being able to play catch with my kids, shooting hurt, I couldnt sleep, and it was miserable.
Do not wait until the impingement causes more damage, as a rotator cuff tear takes 3-4 months to recover from after surgery.
Finkm1, I see you are in MIchigan. I sent you a PM.