I think that for me "traditional" is largely a philosophy.
1) Shooting arrows is fun.
2) Ethical kills are the first consideration when hunting.
I have never made a bow and I've shot POC, laminated birch, hexpine, aluminum and carbon fiber arrows. All my bows right now have some fiberglass in them. I still own the compound I was given for my 14th birthday in 1986. I also own two longbows that I shoot often. The compound hasn't made it out of the case for a long time.
I never understood what traditional referred to, regarding equipment. Just how old is the "tradition" of carbon fiber and fiberglass, anyway? You can always move to older equipment, but does that make you a better archer?
For me, Traditional means what's in my head when I'm shooting.
Good friends having fun shooting.
Hunting and having to get REALLY CLOSE!
Accepting that I could always improve my shooting by falling back on some more technology and (for me) resisting the urge to do so. (But would that make you a better archer?)
Fun question. Thanks for posing it.
Kirk Billings