I took the plunge. Haven't had it in the woods yet. I'm sitting on it now as I type. No doubt but that it's strong and adjustable and comfortable, the main reasons I bought it. However, so far, mine has not proved to be quiet. Generally swivels quietly, but if one leans while swiveling or not, sitting down and getting ouyt of the chair, etc., it often lets out a squeak or groan. Can get by with those noises with turkeys, perhaps, but not deer. That's why I'm sitting in it now. I hope to work out a few of the squeaks before season, or at least figure out where to oil it.