The great schism continues.
When you lower brace height, you change the geometry of the shot in such a way that it makes it more difficult for the arrow to get around the riser, thus making it act stiffer. Yes, the lower bh arrow has more energy imparted to it, but not before the arrow actually clears the riser. The taller bh gets the arrow to arc around the riser, though the power stroke is cut short.
There are experts and amateurs on both sides of this, and both sides observe what they expect.