I don't see what the problem is. Shooting left would be an indication of too stiff for a right handed shooter. Though I'm a bit surprised that cutting off an inch makes them too stiff. On several different bows I have, from cut 1/8 from center to 1/8 past center, I can usually overspine by 10-15# or more with woodies and still get good flight. By cutting an inch off the shaft, you're only increasing the dynamic spine by 5# or so. That shouldn't be enough to make much difference in arrow impact IMO. Regardless, you have two combinations that apparently work well.