Eric,
Like so many of us, I have gone around the whole course on arrow materials.
Way back when, when technology forced me, I switched from cedar to XX75 Gamegetters - as I never could get them danged firberglass logs to fly good. I used 2217's and that shaft quickly became my standard bench mark - a starting point for tuning my bow set-up's. Seems like I can always get a 2117 to work - no matter what. Just have to find the right length, & point weight.
Well, then along came the miracle fiber - carbon. So I embraced it full force. And it is a good arrow material too. But in the last year or so I've found myself going back to the 2217's. Digging thru the "ole-bucket-o-arrows" and finding new treasures. A little re-fletch work and they are as good as new. Fly like darts, with field points or broadheads.
Some things are just meant to work well....
Chinook