If your drawing a true 28", your 2117's should be cut 29"-29 1/4" long. Adapters are 25 grains, Magnus are 30 grains, so your broadhead weight up front is roughly 125.
The 2117's should not come off stiff from either of your setup. Personally, the arrow has to spin true for me, thats why I went to swagged aluminum.
Next, I want 5" or 5.5" feathers in a full helical. As much wrap as I can get from my Bitz.
I draw 27", my 2117's are cut 28.5" and they fly perfectly from my 53# longbow, 55# old Browning Cobra, 57# Groves and 58# Kempf. Make sure your nocking point is adjusted properly, brace height where it should be and if the Kodiak is an older bow, check for twisted limb.
Finally...problem could be your release or something your doing after release, like torquing or dropping the bow arm.....