magnus stinger or woodsman?

[$bowhunter$]

out of the two which do you feel is a beter broadhead for hunting? and why?

[Sixby]

I like them both equally well. I use and reccomend either. If you like pre sharp the stinger of buzzcut,. if you want to sharpen your own the Woodsman. God bless you and have a great evening , Steve

[rastaman]

Both are great heads as long as you have them sharp! i've killed deer and hogs with both. If they are dull, they are both crap...

[RC]

Woodsman.RC

[Friend]

Keep in mind that my choice is only an opinion.

If my set-up will yield a pass thru on most any  likely shot placement, then I would definately select the woodsman.

If my set-up would not yield a pass thru on most any likely shot placement, then I would definately select the stinger.

Perfect shot placement is not the norm and the minimum set-up should be avoided. The bow and the complete arrow design should be prepared for the unexpected.

Just my opinion

[kill shot]

Out of the two, I have only used the stinger. I love em. Razor sharp so they leave a great blood trail. Also super tough. Shot a deer through the shoulder and it only went about 40 yds. Shot through a buck and the arrow stuck in a tree,and bent the head. Magnus sent me a new one.

[Breakfast Boy]

I've used both and love both.  If you're going to use the Stingers, I would suggest the Stinger Buzzcuts.  Mike Sohm, who owns Magnus, told me at the ATA show a few years ago that he uses the Buzzcuts.  I shot an antelope with a Buzzcut last year and the head performed flawlessly.  They fly very nice.

That being said, if you know how to get a three blade razor sharp, either the Woodsmans or the Snuffers do some serious damage when passing through a critter.  I'm using Snuffers now, but any of the three are excellent broadheads in my opinion.

I would say it's simply a matter of if you want to sharpen your own or not like Sixby said.

[Earl Jeff]

They are both good heads. but I like the woodsman.

[Todweelz]

I've used both, magnus leave a nice trail to follow, have'nt had good blood trails with the woodsman, deer keep falling down in sight, really like the woodsman. Todd