Most important thing is that they FIT! Try lots, find the one that fits best and break it in well before hunting. Some guys hunt in Converse Chuck Taylors, some in custom high dollar handmade boots. Your best choice will depend on what kind of hunting you're planning as well, you'll likely choose a different boot for a hike in, live out of your backpack hunt, than a drive in, sleep in a cabin or RV or horseback hunt. I'd suggest that if you are planning on carrying the meat out on your back, get a boot with plenty of ankle support and good traction, such as the Meindl's, Lowa Sheephunter or Tibet, Asolo Sassalong, or Han Wag's. If someone else or a horse is carrying the load, a light day hiker would suit well, something like a Merrell, Vasque, or Lowa, the Danner Pronghorn has a good following as well.