BD- what reason do you have for disliking leather? Keeping broadheads dry?
Tip- I take the foam out of my hood, and using thinned PLASTI-DIP (the plastic tool handle cover dip) I pour the dip into a bowl and cover the foam with a thin coat of the dip- then after it dries most of the way, I slide the foam back into the hood. I do several foams at once to waste as little of the plasti dip as possible. You can pour most of the unused stuff back into the can.
Works great and I also put chapstik on sharpened blades before placing them in my hood foam, to completely keep them dry even in a downpour.
I recommend the Eagles Flight Archery new limb bolt recurve 4 arrow quiver...its very light..and if you treat the leather parts with Montana Pitch Blend it should last a long time.
The difficulty with the non leather types like the Selway black rubber version is that they add significant weight to an already heavier bow.