I'm an old goat, so I don't do nuttin' what don't suite me ..
I shoot both a glove and tab, together. I like a tab that is about 3/32" thick, which is thicker than most retail tabs.
At first I shot 5 tabs stacked because of my arthritic fingers, but my index finger got the old calouse build up...got tired of biting off the calouse.
So, I went to a glove, but the thin leather didn't give my old arthritic joints enough relief.
So, I added a tab to the glove, and now my index finger doesn't get a calouse, and the tab levels out the pressures so my finger joints don't feel so bad.
In extreme cold weather, I find a good cold weather glove and tab works well...or as well as can be expected.
Recently, a club member put me onto the American Leather Big Shot Glove. I tried it and it definitely isn't anything like any glove you've shot. Very stiff, good on the finger joints. It is worth checking out ...
http://www.americanleathers.com/cart/cart.php?target=product&product_id=256&category_id=60