Last year (2009) I hit a mid 150's buck and did not recover It. He lived through It, saw him 4 more times that year. The last time I saw him (December 18th, 2009) I had him at 30 yards but didn't take a shot as It was to far away for me and my recurve. While he was standing broadside at 30 yards I looked at where I hit him and I thought to myself, damn that don't look like to bad of a shot!! Yes It was a little far forward and high but to me I still should've had a dead buck.
Fast forward to 2010 I saw this buck again 4 more times. Had him as close as 11 yards but couldn't get a shot off, too thick of brush. During our ML season he got shot by the neighbors. I heard word of It and went over to the guys place to check out the buck and see where I wounded him In 2009. I hit him In the shoulder blade where I've hit one other deer before. Problem Is, this time It didn't penetrate the shoulder blade enough to get Into the lungs. In 2009 I tried a bigger Snuffer (1 1/2 cutting diameter). 14 years prior to that I've always shot the 1 1/4 cutting diameter Snuffer. If I would've still been shooting the smaller Snuffer that buck would of been mine. I'm not saying there's anything wrong with the big Snuffer but It more then likely did cost me a great buck on a not so good shot on my part. It was just too much bone for that big of a cutting diameter broadhead and my 60lb recurve. I really love Snuffers so In no way am I knocking these heads down. Really It don't matter the head you use, just hit the Intended spot and you'll have a dead animal. I was off by an Inch or 2 but still should've been a dead deer. Still, It's on me though as I didn't hit the spot I was aiming for. 3/4ths the length of the shoulder blade had calcium build up on It. I damn near blew through It but there was just to much metal to get through on an Iffy shot.