i like these 8" uninsulated beans 'cause the tongue is stitched to the entire side and right to the top, making it quite waterproof for the full 8" height. imo, all these bean boots are compromises, that can get you by for different reasons.
that they handle the wet and mud very well is their strong point. however, they're not at all for serious hike-hunting as they don't have the proper last or foot control, and are just too heavy.
i wore these boots last june in sc while pig hunting and they handled all the stalking and slopping in the bogs and streams quite well (well, save for the dang ankle biting).
if the sc terrain wasn't so boggy wet i'd use my 4" hi-tec altitudes , they're an amazing ultra-light boot for spot'n'stalk and serious mountainous hike-hunts.