Any tool is only as good as the experience of the person using it. Many successful sharpening techniques. The "burr" may be influenced by the quality, hardness, & temper of the steel. You may straighten it instead of removing. Bottom line, will your edge shave? Generally, hair popping results from ultra-fine abrasive (polish) properly applied resulting in a very straight sharp edge. This might be your strop w/compound. Or, maybe an ultra-fine stone. Get polish compound or rouge at the hardware store.