john, i use either grayling, bohning, martin or bitz fletchers - don't have a bp.
it's possible that not clipping the tape at the ends of the fletch could be an issue as the glue dot doesn't span the quill and shaft. dunno for sure.
as with any fletching adhesive, cleanliness of shaft and quill, good fletch pressure, fletch end glue dots are paramount. it's gonna be a gamble if your finger oil touches the shaft or quill.
though a taped fletched arrow can be shot immediately after coming out of the fletching jig, the tape also has a "cure" period and will be it's strongest bond within a few hours to overnight.