Ben,I'll tell you what I think and it is pure speculation.I have used Helmsmans a lot and this is a very dry climate.I forget the manufacturers recommendation for recoat time,something like 2 hrs?That hasn't worked for me.If I apply several coats like that,it takes forever to dry.The first coat isn't cured enough,you seal that in with the second,that isn't cured enough and you seal that in with the third and so on.
It worked much better for me if I recoated no sooner than 12 hours.I promise you that the next coat will still adhere well,as the first is nowhere near full cure.After the last coat,I let it hang for several days before installing rest,sideplate and then shooting.I judge the cure of the finish by the odor.When the odor of the finish is almost gone,I feel confident handling the bow for use.
I am convinced that the super glue is causing you no problems.It is a good substrate for about any finish.I wonder if the Helmsmans wasn't applied a little heavier over the skins? If so,and you followed the recommended recoat times,it is just taking longer to cure in that area.
If you have the patience,just let it hang,even if it takes 2 weeks.It will cure if you give it time.If you don't,you could take it off with a paper towel lightly saturated with acetone and go from there.If you refinish them with Helmsmans,try a very light coat,then wait 12-24 hrs before the next coat,don't apply the next coat till the tackiness is gone from the previous.
It dawned on me that you and I are in the same climate.I'm in Whitehall,and it has been cool and damp a lot lately.I think you just need to give it more time.That is the part I hate but it may be just the ticket in this case.