As Homebru said, boots are a very personal thing. I have lived here in Idaho, hunting, hiking and working (I'm a surveyor) in my boots. I have tried them all, for many years believing I needed a heavy soled, ankle-supporting "mountain boot" (I tried them all - Danners, Whites, Asolo etc.) for the rough terrain that we encounter almost everywhere in this state.
After having numerous foot problems, including plantar fasciatous and corns, I now wear Russell moccasins for everything, everyday. I also run in minimalist footwear a couple times a week to strengthen my foot tendons and muscles and keep them strong.
I have found that in rough terrain I have better balance, better traction and better overall control of my movements by using the no-heeled, no orthotic moccasin footwear. G Fred speaks of the improved balance of no-heel shoes in his book on still hunting and I must concur.
The health of my feet has never been better and I will never go back to stiff, heavy type of footwear, but, as said earlier, it is a very individual thing and you have to find out for yourself what works best for you. I'm just saying that "conventional wisdom" sometimes isn't as wise as some would have you believe - including podiatrists.