buzzcut vs. stingers - which is better?

[RUTANDSTRUT]

do you guys think the serrated edge on a buzzcut will give you any advantage (or disadvantage) over the stingers straight edge? (bloodtrails, penetration, hole size, etc.) thnx in advance

[swamprooter]

I shoot plain so I can easily resharpen them, razor sharp out of the package is a myth. Chris

[giff]

it depends on what you like, stingers are 2 blade, buzzcuts are 4

[swamprooter]

Giff, You can get 4 blade stingers too. Chris

[Lamplighter]

I use the 4 blade regular Stinger (non-buzz).  I have killed with both.  Based on Ol School advice about a ultra sharp clean cut ( like when you cut yourself shaving) not giving the blood platlets something to cling to, the non-buzz will deny platlets a cling, so the animal is more likely to continue bleeding.

A jagged cut is rough, and blood platlets immediately cling & begin stopping the bleeding. So, with that, the buzz cut is more of a new gimmick when they came out, knowing that the average joe is sparked by something new every year, a marketing tactic used smartly by camo manuf.   Get the regular stuff man.

[Charlie Lamb]

For what it's worth. CEO of Magnus (Mike Sohm) favors the Buzzcut. Says it does amazing damage.

He's going to send me some to try, so I'll let you know.

I suspect it doesn't matter one little bit.

[JoeM]

Originally posted by Lamplighter:
I use the 4 blade regular Stinger (non-buzz).  I have killed with both.  Based on Ol School advice about a ultra sharp clean cut ( like when you cut yourself shaving) not giving the blood platlets something to cling to, the non-buzz will deny platlets a cling, so the animal is more likely to continue bleeding.

A jagged cut is rough, and blood platlets immediately cling & begin stopping the bleeding. So, with that, the buzz cut is more of a new gimmick when they came out, knowing that the average joe is sparked by something new every year, a marketing tactic used smartly by camo manuf.   Get the regular stuff man.

Exactly!

[sawtoothscream]

the buzzcuts cut is not rough at all, it makes a smooth cut with the way the serrations are designed.  the serrations just add for cutting edges that will grab and cut arteries.  i use to use them in my compound and there nice heads. plus the animal will be dead as can be by the time the wound start clotting.

my buzzcuts came alot sharper then my stinger. my stinger were dull and the buzzcuts shaved hair easy right out for hte pack. i like the buzzcuts more and penetration wise they seem the same to me, both fly the same as well.   ethier way both will kill.

[Sharpster]

Woody Sanford posted an answer to this question on one of the wheelie bow forums a couple years back. Can't find the thread now but he said that the serrations in the Buzz-cuts are there for people who can't get the Stingers as sharp as they could be.

Now don't shoot the messenger...  

Ron

[Shawn Leonard]

Have to agree about the jagged cut theory, try to get a paper cut to stop bleeding, than cut yourself with serrated steak knife, the steak knife cut when squeezed together for a few seconds binds to itself and closes up pretty quick. That said, placed in the right spot both will kill very quickly. Double lung is double lung even with a sharpened stick! Shawn

[TxAg]

buzzcuts don't create a jagged cut any more than the smooth blades create a jagged cut.

Check out the video below. Start at 3:40. He gives the reason for the new design.

 http://www.magnusbroadheads.com/buzzcut.html

I've used both. I will use both this season. I think they're both gona work just fine.

[StephenG]

Goods arguments for both types. One thing that was not mentioned about buzzcuts is that they will produce more resistance drag as they pass into the animal. It may not make enough difference to matter much but it is still fact. My thought is that Fred Bear used straight edge, and if Fred was happy with them then so am I. Remember that most fishing lures are designed to catch more fishermen than fish, same with everything else. Stay with what is proven. You'll be better off in the long run. JMHO

[Spectre]

Grab a roast, a serrated knife, and a regular blade knife. Now slice the roast up using both knives.
 Smoother is better.

[SteveB]

They are a different type of serration than that on a knife(which requires a sawing motion to work). Knife is like a V upside down - buzzcut is more square and does not leave a jagged edge while cutting thru in one direction and do not cause more drag. Each leading edge of the serration acts like the tip of the broadhead.

[ranger 3]

How do you sharpen a serrated edge?

[Breakfast Boy]

You sharpen the Buzzcuts just like you do the Stingers.  My wife shoots a compound and after I spoke with Mike Sohm at a trade show a few years ago, we went with the Buzzcuts for her.  He's the one that told me to sharpen them like the Stingers.  I figure if the owner of a broadhead company picks the Buzzcut out of all his products, and that's what he personally uses, then that's good enough for me!  Lol!  Although I have to say, I use the VPA Terminators out of my longbow and I don't think you can find a better broadhead than VPA.  Lol!

[Sharpster]

Originally posted by ranger 3:
How do you sharpen a serrated edge?

Grind off the serrations, then sharpen as usual,    

Ron

[TxAg]

Originally posted by ranger 3:
How do you sharpen a serrated edge?

check out the link I posted on the first page. It's a video of him sharpening.

[beachbowhunter]

Originally posted by Charlie Lamb:
For what it's worth. CEO of Magnus (Mike Sohm) favors the Buzzcut. Says it does amazing damage.

He's going to send me some to try, so I'll let you know.

I suspect it doesn't matter one little bit.

Charlie is right as ususal. I shoot both in the 150 grain with bleeders configuration. They both work great. I agree that touch ups are easier with the straight edge. Because I have quit fussing with broadheads and settled on the Stinger, I use both so I at least have SOME variability.

[eflanders]

Mike Sohm told me that the lower  the poundage you shoot, the more benificial the Buzzcut is.  He used to respond on quite a few of the archery forums and he was very consistant in his advice.  I believe I had heard somewhere that he has walked away from the broadhead side of the business now though...