I do not like making a arrows so I use whatever flies the best and is heavy. Don't much care if they are cane, wood, or carbon, as long as they hit the spot picked; that is, if I don't misremember (Mark,is that a word? you're the writer) and forget to pick one. Getting old and senile according to the wife so I got a good excuse. Anyway, back to the arrows. Won't shoot the black carbons anymore, they are hard to see in low light conditions. This may be a satistical anomaly (Simpson's paradox), but I almost always get a complete pass through with heavy carbons, from a 58# selfbow, on deer and rarely get them with wood arrows from the same bow. Basically, in the words of Tim Ott, it don't matter much, dead its dead and the deer doesn't care which type arrow killed him.