Im not seeing 4 1/2. I am not expert but have reviewed this subject lately. My old man has land and he has his rules on the deer killed there. So I had to learn.
So not trying to be confrontational, and mainly looking to improve my deer aging skills I will tell you what I see and hopefully my and many others aging skill can be honed a little.
First picture I see the deer's belly isnt puffing out like an older deer in the 6 and up range have MOST of the time so I do know the deer still has life and good bone growth years to come. Also I see a slender neck. I do not know if they are in the rut down there or if they were when the picture was taken but its neck is small.
The second picture further more shows me the skinnyness of the neck. Also it starts to show me the face and how the skin around it is still tight.
The third picture shows the back and belly. Its back isnt drooped from age nor is the belly. The forth picture show the same stuff. What I cant see is the deer walking which would show the deers stride. Just like humans the young ones have a different walk than the older folks.
Im not saying you are wrong by any means I just put out there what I see and what signs I have to age the deer. If I am wrong in my sightings please tell me. If you want that horrible looking deer taken care of please tell me as well. I can be over there tomorrow!!
Edit: This is the main site I have used to fine tune the witch craft they call aging deer. I have look at many other site but this one helped out the most. I also tried every aging deer contest I could find on the net.
http://www.1atexasdeerhunting.com/bodyagingdeer.htm Kyle