Actually,OL says it doesn't matter how well you group.You just shoot bare shaft and fletched and average the results.You can't do it with one group.
If you can move back to 15 yds or whatever,it will help.
The good thing about trying to make your existing .500's work,is,that if you improve form and increase draw length later,you can always reduce point weight to get the right tune.if you go to .600's and a 125 gr head,and later increase draw length,reducing head weight really compromises your choices in broadheads.
Either way,I would want to tune those .500's since you have them.Once you see exactly what they need foe point weight and what their overall weight is,you can make a rational decision as to whether you need .500's or .600's.
Read OL's tuning information,thoroughly.