I was on the same "search" as you a few months ago. I shoot 3 under and tried Bateman Cordovan, Black Widow 3-under (I think the call it Super Leather?), and the AAE.
I found the AAE to be kinda bit, and a little cumbersome in daily use. Not easy to "pivot" the tab to the back of my hand to pull arrows and such. A nice tab, but I found I didn't need all the extras it provides.
The BW 3-under is nicely made, but is a little "bulky" for me. I also couldn't really get used to the way the tab is "split" for each finger. The little piece of leather that faces the arrow seemed like a nice idea, but it just added to the bulk.
The Bateman 3-under fits me perfectly, and the padding is just enough for my 45# bow. Some people don't like the elastic loop, and for some it has apparently worn out pretty quick. But I like the loose but secure fit of the elastic. It allows me to quickly and easily spin the tab to the back of my hand. And it has - so far 4-5 months of daily shooting - held up just fine. The elastic is riveted in place, but I think it would be fairly easy to replace if/when needed.
So Bateman 3-under Cordovan for me.
Henrik