Owlbait,
Where are you and your buddies hunting? Like you mentioned before, down near Zanesville? I used to own a small farm down there(7 miles south of Zanesville) and many HUGE bucks were shot on, in and around my old property. A 209 inch non-typical was shot off that property 3 years ago.
Chester,
To keep this tied into the original question; I have personally seen 150 class bucks, maybe bigger, down on Trivalley Wildlife area. 2 1/2 hour drive from Canton. I also agree with looking onto Saltfork State Park area. I used to fish and camp there as a kid. Ridiculous amounts of deer near the golf course!
All the above being said, I couldn't care less personally about trophy antlers. They are nice, but I love seeing any deer period! They all give me the shakes when they get close.