Welcome Doug!
Glad to have you on board. There is plenty of good advice here. I don't know of any local shops that specialize in traditional gear. Tollgate Traditions, east of you, was a great resource but they have recently scaled back their store. Very unfortunate. There is a really good tradional archery rendezvous down in Oxford, NY later in August. Maybe an hour or hour and a half drive from Cicero. It might be worth the drive down. There ia a thread on the Events and Gatherings forum with all the information. By the way, I lived in Cicero for 40 years!