YOu make great points, Mike...
All but your conclusion that those of us who "support" Kirk are "buddies."
Did you ever stop to think that after some of us who've been around the block a few times, speak highly of Kirk because the experience is defintely a totally different one from the "big names" who have more bows "out there?"
I met kirk on line. he responded to my very personal detailed history of bowyers and custom (?) bows and my need for something "more."
Thru that process, we stepped on one another's toes more than a few times, but he's smart enough and secure enough in his work that he could tell my challenges were from the heart...as I would wish to believe
are your own.Difference is that I paid my freight and then challenged the devil out of Kirk to "prove to me" what he said...and by golly, he DID prove it!
He sent me videos of top contenders' limb designs...showed me how some continue to oscillate till morning while his stop dead in their tracks... transferring more energy into the arrow. Not once was there a whisper of who built the "other limbs". That's integrity!
For those who look for such character issues, they are found in some, not so easily in others. We all have opinions like body parts!
I met Kirk briefly at B'more...he did spend an hour with me taking videos, but his openness, honesty and candor, even to the point of calling BS on various of my beliefs about arrows and such, built a "TRUST" in him that lingers.
Buddies? I'd hardly say so. Don't know the man well enough, but in the months we've exchanged a lot of emails and phone conversations and that bit of personal face time, I've come to trust, respect and believe in the man's talent, his heart and his dedication to never quit and to make the best product for the customer.
If other bowyers who built ME bows shot hundred arrows thru my bow before delivery...they didn't mention it. I never got a suggested brace height..nor a nock point set that so far, with Kirk's bow, WORKS!
Buddies? I don't think that is a wise choice of words...and as a school teacher you know vocabulary is powerful stuff. Respect? You bet!
I know several bowyers well enough to "like them as people" but I've not seen the level of dedication to go "above and beyond."
If that sounds like a commercial, so be it. I'm impressed!
If there is one thing I know it's economics and ROI..this man couldn't give a flying flip if he's making money as much as if he's making a great product with a bunch of solid research behind every aspect of it.
Kirk not only "pushes the envelope"...which to my reading suggests he's on the cutting edge. If I've portrayed that his efforts are just "far out experiments" ,i.e, "cutting edge" without substance, in my missive, I've failed miserably.
What I would have preferred to have communicated is that Kirk doesn't take what is "accepted belief" and build on THAT WITHOUT testing it first!
I'd prefer to think of that as going back and building a solid foundation on "known testing" and proven factors, not presumptions and hearsay or what other more established craftsman
believe is true.
I don't mean to sound defensive, Mike, but I made my living for a lot of my life with words...words are power, and some choices tend to paint pictures that need to be challenged.
I made the point early on that I choose Kirk because he is "data driven"... BS walks and testing talks in my world.
Cutting edge be damned. Testing what is believed "truisms" takes some courage and cajones... if one finds that the status quo has holes in it, then sure...I guess you could call that "cutting edge"...but not as in "radical departures from tried and TESTED & proven stuff.
I have 3 bows in my new bows draw range. This bow is smoother, lighter in "felt draw" and yet it zings my standard 585 grain EFOC arrows better than my others who clock in with higher draw weights....oh...and it actually FITS my hand.
Anecdotes from a
buddy?[/i] I think that is what rankles a bit...I'm not his buddy. I've become a "fan" working with the man and experiencing an interaction like I've never known with any other "custom" bowyer. I paid for that experience and that opinon. Thank you very much!
For true and certain, there is not enough of my $$ to go around and experience ALL the bowyers out there who are superb! And perhaps you've had similar experiences, but it feels rather degrading to relegate my experiences to being his "buddy" and "back patting". I take exception to those particular thoughts in print.
My experience with Kirk generates respect...and a bit of loyalty when the proof is in the pudding and I have shot the pudding and like the results!
Back patting? There is an old expression I'm tempted to drag out...it ain't braggin when it's truth!
To each his own. You have your obvious favorites from your many posts.
I took a "wait and see" approach...sifted and sorted and let the chaff be separated from the grain.
God bless America and the free enterprise system. Your dollars speak as loudly as mine and the rest who have paid the anty and found superiority! Amen.
Ply your dollars wisely but
please don't denigrate my learned experiences to some sophomoric "fan club" or 'buddy' experience.
Thank you for clarifying your position in a much shorter reply than my own... but again, words are power and you used some powerful, if not potentially mis-interpreted vocab in your post that I hope I've set straight with some careful and respectful counters.