I went all traditional during the hunting season of 2009. I even sold my $1,000 PSE compound set up. I didn't have a shot at a deer in range (compound, recurve, or otherwise) that entire year. But, I had moved for a job and was hunting a new area I was completely unfamiliar with. I saw deer, just nothing in my wheel house.
Last year I decided I needed to get some meat in the freezer and bought myself a used compound. I ended up getting two does (both less than 15y shots) and one with a smokepole late in the season. So, my freezer was again full of meat. I spent the rest of that year searching for a doe with the trad bow, but the deer were real skittish and I never had anything in range.
Back to this year, I'm hunting again with the wheels and ended up shooting my largest buck ever ( a 150 and 2/8") 9 pt at 22y with my compound. I decided to shelve that bow (maybe for good, not quite sure yet) and try to fill doe tags with my trad bow. Of course I've only seen bucks since Oct 20 and not a single doe in range.
Funny how that works....But if you want to dedicate yourself to 100% trad, just do it. Best way to is to sell the wheels and stay committed. If you enjoy the meat, you may want to hunt a gun season to fill the freezer and spend the rest of the time on your quest with the trad bow.
Somedays it's all about the hunt (most times) and others I'm after some meat. Either way, I want to hunt with the weapon that will make the most humane kill.
My decision to go back to the wheels is due mostly to not practicing enough with the trad bow. I recently got back into fishing, purchased a small fishing boat, so I spent most of my off-hunting season time fishing instead of shooting like I did in 2009.