Interesting how opinions and experiences are so very different on states, private, public, etc. land.
The best hunting spot I every haunted was on the IN/MI state line (IN side) in Elkhart County, Indiana. I moved from that area way back in 1985 and have never forgotten it.
I lived in KS and worked for KDWP from 89-92. It was the worst deer hunting of my life and I had 1.5 miles of small river private habitat to hunt (west of Newton). Of course I've seen the pictures of big KS deer, the TV shows, etc. It was EXTREMELY difficult to find private land access. I trust the new walk-in hunting program is providing more public opportunity.
I am most fond of hunting in states with statewide quality management programs -- in other words, one buck rule states. My favorites are KY and IN. When I go west I pursue "exotic" beasts instead of whitetails.