I have had an old style Coleman Scanoe (aluminum frame) for around a dozen years and love it. Bought it after fishing out of a buddies Scanoe for a while. They are stable enough for one guy to stand and fish and can carry a good-sized load. I live in East TN and the rocks in the rivers can be rough on boats. The scanoe has some battle scars, but is still in good shape. The frame tends to slide over rocks instead of sticking like aluminum does. I have a 34 lb. trolling motor on it and it will push it pretty well even with my big butt and gear in it. It isn't horrible to paddle, but the square stern doesn't slide through the water like a standard canoe will. Have run mild Class 3s in it, but wouldn't recommend making a habit of it. I generally line it through rapids where I don't want to risk losing my gear. The major downside to the Scanoe is the weight. Mine tips the scales at around 120 pounds. I can load it on the roof rack by myself without too much of a problem, but I'm not a little guy. Although hope to work on that some this spring!
The best canoe for you will depend on exactly what you want it for. If you need a canoe that will run heavy rapids and/or be good for paddling long distances, then the Scanoe probably isn't your best bet. If you want ultra-stability and load hauling with the option of using a trolling motor to get where you want to go without having to paddle much, then I would definitely put the Scanoe on my short list.
Good luck and hope you enjoy whatever one you get. But be careful. Like with bows, canoes and kayaks can get addictive! Having just one won't do. I'm now up to a canoe and 3 kayaks. :rolleyes: