I shot a bunch of different wood arrows- cedar, compressed and tapered cedar, ash, maple, sitka spruce. I still prefer the compressed cedars as I found them to be the toughest for the weight. However, as you noted, the weight varies a lot. I did not worry about it. Instead I found that if you could keep spines close, weight variations did not matter so much. Right now I am on the edge of getting back into traditional full time. As such I am shooting some XX75 2018s. Once I make the full plunge, I plan on going back to compressed cedars.