Sean -Are you shooting longbow or recurve? Also I noticed that most of the responses are for gloves that cover most of your hand. I guess that's OK for those of you that live up north in states that huddle up together just to stay warm in the winter.
However, down here in Texas it tends to get get pretty warm in the winter and downright hot in the summer. So, if you do any shooting at all, you find yourself with a sweaty glove and a wet glove creates all sorts of release issues.
I shoot longbows and therefore really like the traditional finger stall gloves with a thin leather lace or strap that connects the stall with a wrist strap. The stall can be easily slipped off the end of the fingers and allowed to air dry between shots. It also makes it easy to write down scores during a 3D Shoot without wearing gloves over your writing fingers.
My favorite for years has been the E.W. Bateman Traditional Glove made with cordovan leather. It takes a little breaking in, but I think it is the best glove on the market, bar none.
Danny