I have had both canoes and kayaks. Both have their advantages and disadvantages, although I wouldn't want to make a generalization about either type of watercraft. A while back I sold my kayak and bought a solo canoe(15'& 48#'s). Like a lot of things it comes down to personal preference, but here is why I like the canoe over the kayak: my canoe is lighter that a similar sized kayak making it easier to carry/transport, it is easier to load gear into and out of, it can carry more gear than my kayak could, it has more seating positions which make for a more comfortable paddle, being older I found that the canoe was easier to get into and out of, my canoe probably isn't as stable as the kayak-but it is well designed and I have no trouble with it being 'tippy' and fish out of it on a regular basis with no problem. Lastly, my 70# Lab will not fit as well in a kayak, and she almost always goes with me. If I was going to pick another boat other than a canoe, and hunting, camping, and fishing were what I planned to use it for I would probably look hard at the Native Watercraft 14 1/2' Ultimate.