Mike, I have only two bows. My first custom longbow was a Thunderstick Mag I bought years ago and still have. I just picked up a Whip HS and it is the closest I have found in accuracy, quietness, and smoothness compared to the Tstick. I love longbows, so staying with a longbow would be my thing, maybe a take-down model in the whip in case you needed it! But I do love the look of the superD as well, so that would be a tough choice. Fit/finish, I have owned a few and Toelke is at the top of the game!