Wasn't trying to win any arguments...didn't mean it that way, Ron...
But this whole issue is very VERY location specific.
I meet guys who say it matters not... close questioning reveals that they have pretty sizeable private ground where outside influences are mitigated!
As far as I'm concerned, having hunted archery in PA since close to when we started a special season, I say we now have a 2 week archery season... and after that...deer I hunt, where I hunt, run thru the woods like it's opening day of Rifle Season!!!
Suffice it to say that I have to drive 2-3 hrs to get where I hunt, so I'm handicapped in doing a lot of scouting with gas prices. Second, there is none of this "hunt the wind" stuff... I can't circle around depending on the wind, as the acreage I have permission to hunt, is surrounded by posted property...
I'm sure dedicated hunters, who can spend goodly amounts of time in their hunting areas, can likely find escape routes to hunt and avoid some of the negative factors...
And yes, Ron, I've hunted daylight to dark, come out, go back in the next day in the dark, and find FRESH rubs/scrapes that were NOT there the day before...so it's all over night activity!
Down at Muddy Run project, the care taker told me 30 yrs ago, his deer count INSIDE the refuge doubled by NOON of the first day of archery season (surrounded on 3 sides by Game Lands) and the count remained up till Feb 1 when ALL seasons had closed!
Talk about response to pressure!