I only have experience with one on your list. I carried a CatQuiver Mini for a decade. Most of that time I was hunting with a compound, having switched to Trad a few years ago.
I loved the Mini, but a couple times I found my bowstring inside the bottom part of the quiver with my broadheads. I was fortunate that it never cut my string. I remedied this by putting a thin rubber band around both sides of the quiver. This keeps the string away from sharp objects, and it is also easy enough to pull off if a shot presents itself while walking to or from the stand.
It wasn't one of your listed options, but I'm going with the Safari Tuff Arrowmaster this season.