Carbons work well and there pretty durable, I know you have to set them up a lot weaker than you think.
But all said and done give me my woodies back, I don't think they are any better but I like them more. If for no other reason than they just go with a Hill style bow.
As far as durability goes, Id like to know how people break wood arrows so easy. I shoot a lot of stumps and such and miss 3D targets as much as the next guy but I rarely break one. I've sent a woody into some horrific crashes and have seen others do the same, but they seem to survive just fine.
And the last reason, as insignificant as it may be, I make my own woodies and manage to get a few that look pretty decent. But you cant dress up a carbon or aluminum arrow, its like putting a gold earing on a hog.
Eric