A properly made and broken in Hill style quiver is not loud, nor does it dull up two blade heads. When broken in, they are flat to the back. A wide three blade head can be a problem for them, I don't like three blade heads so it is not an issue for me. I sometimes hunt with aluminum arrows, if I am dancing around enough to make my arrows rattle, I am not hunting, I am dancing. Normal walking moving around and shooting it is not an issue. The last two hard leather quivers I bought from HHA came quite round. The guys I gave them too, got them to flatten out very nicely with some NEETS Oil, heat and wearing them snug until they broke in. You can also get the flexible quiver from HHA, not much break in required at all. A good Hill style quiver is much more than just a tube to toss arrows into, it becomes a functional part of the hunt.