According to a press release I saw from ODNR, they will be happy if the overall deer harvest is down another 10-15% again this year. They are saying that it demonstrates a decrease in the herd and that is their goal.
As far as accidental shooting of bucks during muzzleloader season goes, my favorite county saw a 30% increase in the number of bucks harvested just after the DOE ONLY muzzleloader season. They were down almost 16% before the doe only season and then somehow miraculously they were up 15% after the doe only season. That 30% swing in the math which doesn't add up to good things....
I'm not saying anything was intentional, but the county shouldn't go from a deficit of bucks to a surplus after a doe season.
Somebody shot the wrong thing.....