Another minwax, fiebing, or lost nation stain user along with minwax wipe on poly gloss user. Let the stain dry a day and then depending on temp and humidity it usually takes about 3 to 8 hours for the wipe on poly to dry with steel wool 0000 in between coats. I usually do 4 coats then crest with a water based paint, let that dry and do one last coat of the wipe on poly and let that dry overnight before I fletch. Try to let the arrows sit a full 24 hours between the last coat of poly and when I actually shoot them. No fumes, no mess besides a dirty cloth from the stain and wipe on poly and I can get everything from a local Wally World or hardware store. The finish on the commercial dip stuff is definitely harder but to me since I can only make them in the house is not worth the fumes.