Big Jim Buffalo or A&H ACS

[TaterHill Archer]

I'm thinking on a 2-piece longbow and would like to hear from anyone that has shot both.  Thanks in advance.

[bowfanatik]

BigJim Buffalo all the way
My view is expressed with the technical side, I know how hard it is to make a bow. I know it's even harder to make a two-part system. I reviewed his video where he makes two-piece bow and I am aware that this is one of the best if not the best. But let's not forget, his bows artworks .. every one of them. Of course this is just my opinion. Look at these photos as an example     PHOTO

[hitman]

Those are things of beauty. Way to go Big Jim.  

[VictoryHunter]

I just ordered one of Big Jim's bows as well. I haven't shot one yet but have heard nothing but good things.

[SAVIOUR68]

If money was no object A&H all the way.

[Chad Orde]

Both good choices I own one Thunder Child and one Buffalo

[riverrat 2]

My A&H is one of the best performing longbows I've ever owned. I had a Buffalo,and a Thunderchild. Between the Buffalo and the Thunderchild,I liked the Thunderchild better. Jims bows are a lot prettier than the A&H's IMO. But the best advice I'd offer is try to shoot them both.  rat'

[Dendy Cromer]

Big jim. No doubt.

[Mr. fingers]

Big Jim all the way
His craftsman ship is unsurpassed , flawless  he makes the most beautiful bows I have ever seen.  And they shoot as good as they look.
You will like Jim  I have been on the phone with him a few times and its like talking to one of your hunting buddies.
He a good dude..

[TaterHill Archer]

Thanks everyone.  I like the grip on the ACS, but the Buffalo grip looks good too.

[Todd Cook]

I think it would be hard to go wrong either way.

[coaster500]

One of the best things about traditional bows is holding one in your hand. Looking at the warmth and beauty of the woods....... and yes finding one that fits and functions for you.

Jim builds some of the most beautiful bows I have ever seen and they shoot spot on for me,,, as far as grips go just tell Jim what you want??? I've owned a couple of AH ACS bows but found they were not the best fit for me.

You need to shoot both and decide for yourself but for me it's hands down Big Jim...........

[awbowman]

Fit is important.  

All being equal in fit if you want beauty and better than average performance go with Jim.  If you want one of the best performing bows around go A&H. Hands down a better performer.

Of course that's my opinion

[larry]

not many bows can compete with an A&H 2 pcs. when it comes to speed and stability. And you already like the grip...but they sure aren't as pretty as Big Jim's. Guess it all depends on what you want, do you want to look at it or shoot it?

[elkken]

Originally posted by riverrat 2:
My A&H is one of the best performing longbows I've ever owned. I had a Buffalo,and a Thunderchild. Between the Buffalo and the Thunderchild,I liked the Thunderchild better. Jims bows are a lot prettier than the A&H's IMO. But the best advice I'd offer is try to shoot them both.  rat'

X2 ... I have owned all three and the A&H is "the" shooter of the three and the TC would be second of the three.

[TaterHill Archer]

Guys thaanks for the info.  I love a beautiful bow, but have reached the point of wanting a smooth bow, more than a beauty.

I may have a chance to buy a used 2-piece A&H, but it's a 64" bow.  I'm really wanting one in 60".  I know a 64" bow would be sweet though.  It's grey diamond wood, so not pretty, but it's ok to me.

[Bjorn]

I have shot A&H bows for the past 10 years-one piece, two piece, and 3 piece and 62"-66" lengths. The 64" bow is the best all around bow they make IMO. I have not shot the 60" bow.

[nineworlds9]

Tater, I would think beyond the shooting characteristics of the two and make more of a decision about whether you are looking for raw performance or a custom made functional artwork that also happens to perform at top level?  IMHO you're comparing apples and pears, kinda like do I get the BMW/Benz, or the Ferrari?  Anything Big Jim will be smooth and quick, individually made to your artistic desire and specs-  a thing of beauty.  To me in this comtext the A&H is more of a production item that is more focused on function rather than form, though no doubt they do look good.  As far as BJim bows, the TC will do everything the Buff will, just in a smaller package.  The A&H would be more appropriately compared to a 2pc Centaur and the Buff/TC to a 2pc Whip or Caribow.  Just my 2cents.  In summary what is truly important to you?

[T-Bowhunter]

Big Jim, I love my Thunder Child!

[Tradtical Commando]

I am on the list for one of Big Jims bows. Ive never even held one but based on reputation alone (both Jims and especially his bows), a person cannot possibly go wrong with one.